Field report SE-6 / R4 · sheet /macro

Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory

Chemical Industry Chief: Net Zero Depends on Rosebank's Oil

SCI chief Sharon Todd says medicines, fertilisers and green tech all depend on hydrocarbon feedstocks, making Rosebank essential — though her case lacks field-specific numbers.

Grid
SE-6 / R4
Surveyed
November 17, 2026
Reading
4 min read
Correspondent
Sophie Lindqvist
The road to net zero relies on Rosebank
Fig. SE-6 / R4The road to net zero relies on Rosebank — wasi1370 / pixabay

Field notes

  1. SCI CEO Sharon Todd OBE argues the Rosebank oil field decision is essential to net zero because hydrocarbons remain critical feedstocks for medicines, fertilisers and green technology.
  2. A report by SCI and the National Preparedness Commission, published a year ago, warned of grave consequences for UK resilience if hydrocarbon production ends.
  3. Carbon Brief data cited in the piece shows Chinese chemical production CO2 emissions rose 12 per cent in 2025.
  4. Todd says no alternative to fossil fuel-based feedstocks currently exists at the scale modern life requires.

The road to net zero runs through the Rosebank oil field, according to Sharon Todd OBE, chief executive of SCI (the former Society of Chemical Industry, a 140-year-old industry body). Her argument, made in a new opinion intervention, is simple: Britain will still need oil and gas as raw material long after it electrifies transport and decarbonises power.

Todd writes: "The medicines we rely on, the clothes we wear, the smartphones we carry and much of the infrastructure that powers the green transition all depend on hydrocarbon sources like Rosebank."

What does this change for the Rosebank decision? On Todd's reading, it reframes the debate from a binary clash between climate ambition and extraction into a question of industrial supply chains — though her case rests more on assertion than on quantified alternatives.

What is actually being claimed?

The core contention is that oil and gas are not merely fuels. They are feedstocks (raw materials converted into chemical products) for medical equipment, medicines, plastics, clothing, detergents, packaging, electronics, paints, adhesives and fertilisers.

Todd points to a report published a year ago by SCI and the National Preparedness Commission, Industrial Resilience: Assessing the Foundations of UK Industry. It warned of "grave consequences" for UK resilience, security and prosperity if policymakers equate the transition to a low-carbon economy with the end of hydrocarbon production. That view, the report argued, is "fundamentally flawed".

Notably, neither the report's specific findings nor any production volumes for Rosebank appear in Todd's argument. The piece names no reserve estimates, no employment figures and no timeline for when alternatives might reach scale — a gap critics will press on.

Which sectors depend on fossil carbon?

Todd's list of dependencies is long:

  • Healthcare: many pharmaceutical ingredients derive from hydrocarbons; syringes, protective equipment, IV bags and medical devices all depend on fossil-based materials.
  • Agriculture: fertilisers rely on hydrocarbon feedstock inputs.
  • Green technology itself: batteries, wind turbines and solar panels depend on carbon supply chains that trace back to hydrocarbon feedstocks.

She concedes that alternative carbon routes are in development. But she insists none can replace fossil feedstocks "at the scale required by modern life" — limited, she says, by cost, scale and practicality. No cost comparison or capacity figures accompany that claim.

Is Rosebank incompatible with climate goals?

Todd rejects the framing that new North Sea developments contradict Britain's climate ambitions. Halting domestic production, she argues, does not stop consumption; it merely shifts supply abroad, often with a higher carbon footprint and long-distance transport added on top.

Her one hard statistic comes from Carbon Brief: CO2 emissions from chemical production in China rose by 12 per cent in 2025. "Most people may be shocked to think that we may be relying on coal derived products which come with a significantly worse carbon footprint," she writes. A nation serious about decarbonisation, she adds, "should not willingly accelerate its dependence on imports thinking this is improving the UK's carbon footprint. The opposite is the reality."

The counterargument — that Rosebank's oil is largely exported, or that Scope 3 emissions (those from burning the extracted product) dominate its footprint — goes unaddressed in her piece.

What about supply chain fragility?

Todd invokes the pandemic, the war in Ukraine and Middle East tensions as evidence that global supply chains fail under stress. In a major trade disruption, she writes, "many of the products and industrial capabilities upon which modern Britain depends quickly come under strain".

Energy security, she argues, is only one part of the picture; industrial security matters just as much. The sensible course, in her telling, is to pursue both at once — cutting emissions through innovation while keeping domestic manufacture of hydrocarbon-derived products secure.

What is left unsaid?

The Rosebank decision, Todd concludes, is "not a simple black and white choice between the future and the past" but "a symbol of how decisions will be made", and key choices must be informed by science as well as economics. "For a country that claims to value energy security, industrial resilience, decarbonisation and strategic independence, that should not be a difficult decision."

What remains unanswered is the practical question any regulator will ask: how much of Rosebank's output would actually serve UK feedstock needs rather than refined fuel markets, and on what timeline alternatives could realistically close the gap. Until those numbers surface, her case is a supply chain argument, not yet a field-specific one.

via cityam.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

483 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous articleNext article »

End of sheetSE-6 / R4 · November 17, 2026