Field report S-91 / J9 · sheet /expansion

Expansion & MarketsFiled from the territory

Walmart closures leave nearby traffic and revenue 25% below baseline

A study of 39 Walmart closures finds nearby traffic and revenue fell about 25% against comparison areas, showing that losing an anchor can hurt rivals despite reduced competition.

Grid
S-91 / J9
Surveyed
November 17, 2026
Reading
4 min read
Correspondent
Olivia Hart
When a Walmart disappears, here’s what happens to nearby stores. It’s not what you’d expect
Fig. S-91 / J9When a Walmart disappears, here’s what happens to nearby stores. It’s not what you’d expect — 652234 / pixabay

Field notes

  1. The sample covered 39 Walmart closures across 20 states from 2019 to 2026.
  2. Nearby traffic and sales fell roughly 25% versus businesses near Walmart stores that remained open.
  3. The relative decline widened from 5% in month one to 17% in month nine and 20% in month 12.
  4. Direct competitors, recognizable brands and businesses with higher online revenue shares posted better results.

By Olivia Hart

Monthly shopper traffic and sales revenue at nearby shops fell by roughly 25% relative to comparable outlets after Walmart closed, according to a study of 39 closures across 20 states.

Shoppers may mourn the loss while competitors celebrate, but nearby businesses had more reason to worry. The study shows that Walmart functions as both a formidable rival and a traffic anchor, making its closure a net loss for many surrounding businesses.

Marketing scholars Vivek Astvansh, Preetinder Kaur and Pushpinder Gill said: “We found that nearby stores saw a slump in both monthly shopper traffic and sales revenue by roughly a quarter in contrast to comparable stores near Walmart locations that remained open.”

Their sample covers Walmart stores that closed from 2019 through 2026. They combined closure dates with monthly store-level traffic and spending data, then compared nearby non-Walmart businesses with businesses around Walmarts that remained open.

What does the anchor effect change?

Walmart competes for visits and spending, but its scale also gives shoppers a reason to travel to an entire shopping area. A trip for groceries, household goods, meals or services can produce another stop at a restaurant, pharmacy, salon, specialty retailer or local service provider.

Economists describe that benefit as the agglomeration effect: businesses gain when proximity itself attracts shoppers. Shopping-center owners have long used prominent stores to anchor tenant mixes and draw footfall around them.

Previous research found that Walmart’s entry lowers sales at existing nearby shops, which can respond by changing assortments, prices and promotions. Until this study, economists had not tested what happens when Walmart, or another anchor store, closes.

That reversal produces a tug of war. Competitive relief frees some demand from Walmart, but agglomeration loss leaves fewer people entering the retail cluster. A neighboring store can capture a larger share of spending and still earn less if the overall customer pool contracts.

How large was the decline?

The measured gap widened steadily after closure. Nearby stores registered declines of about 5% in the first month and 6% in the second, compared with businesses near stores that remained open.

By the ninth month, the decline reached approximately 17%. It expanded to 20% one year after the closure, according to the researchers.

Traffic and revenue moved together. Had the same shoppers simply spent less at each visit, spending per visit would have fallen; instead, fewer shoppers visited neighboring businesses.

This pattern indicates that competitive relief did not offset the lost trips generated by Walmart. The anchor’s departure reduced the size of the destination market for businesses with no direct contractual relationship to it.

Which businesses absorbed the shock better?

Stores competing directly with Walmart recorded better post-closure sales than noncompeting outlets. Grocery retailers and other close substitutes were better positioned to absorb demand for products shoppers previously bought at the closed store.

Recognizable brands also outperformed unbranded businesses. A familiar name gave customers an independent reason to visit, while stores located among more outlets carrying their own brands also produced more favorable results after closure.

Digital reach provided another buffer. Businesses generating a higher proportion of revenue from online orders suffered smaller sales declines because they depended less on customers physically traveling to the store cluster.

The evidence points to two practical options:

  • Open another location to reduce reliance on visits to the wider retail cluster.
  • Expand online sales so revenue depends less on anchor-generated footfall.

Neither option removes the broader traffic shock, but both give a retailer another route to customers.

What should owners and local officials do?

Managers should not treat a rival’s exit as an automatic windfall. They need to estimate how many customers visit because of the wider destination, not merely how directly their products overlap with the anchor’s assortment.

Property owners face a similar calculation. Replacing the tenant quickly can limit vacancy, but the replacement must also generate trips that sustain restaurants, pharmacies, salons and other tenants across the portfolio.

Local governments and economic-development organizations should look beyond the vacant unit. Their options include:

  • Accelerating redevelopment of the closed property.
  • Coordinating with businesses and owners to improve shoppers’ access.
  • Creating a new destination capable of restoring footfall.

The wider lesson is straightforward: an anchor store creates an externality, transmitting economic value to neighboring businesses without compensation through the anchor’s own prices or profits. Its closure can therefore turn a site-level decision into a neighborhood-level shock.

Astvansh is associate professor of quantitative marketing and computational data science at Binghamton University, State University of New York. Kaur is assistant professor of marketing at the University of Guelph, and Gill is assistant professor of marketing at Toronto Metropolitan University.

via fastcompany.com/rss (Source)

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

458 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous articleNext article »

End of sheetS-91 / J9 · November 17, 2026