Field report SE-46 / N1 · sheet /macro

Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory

PM Burnham's EU Emissions Deal Would Raise Energy Bills, Warns Think Tank

Prosperity Institute analysis says UK-EU emissions trading linkage would raise carbon prices 32%, while scrapping green levies would cut bills £7.2bn a year.

Grid
SE-46 / N1
Surveyed
November 18, 2026
Reading
4 min read
Correspondent
Priya Raman
Closer ties to the EU will do nothing to bring down energy costs
Fig. SE-46 / N1Closer ties to the EU will do nothing to bring down energy costs — geralt / pixabay

Field notes

  1. Prosperity Institute calculates UK-EU ETS linkage would raise British carbon prices by around 32 per cent.
  2. Government claims linkage saves exporters £800m; cited report also shows a £3.5–8bn economic hit from avoidable carbon taxes.
  3. Scrapping Climate Change Levy, Carbon Price Support, UK ETS and UK CBAM would cut bills £7.2bn a year — about £250 per household.
  4. Abolition would cost the Exchequer £4.2bn gross and deliver a long-run GDP boost of up to £7.4bn.
  5. Burnham attends the UK-EU Summit in Brussels on Friday to sign agreements on food, energy and youth mobility.

Linking the UK and EU emissions trading schemes would push British carbon prices up by roughly 32 per cent, according to new analysis that directly challenges Prime Minister Andy Burnham's flagship energy plan ahead of Friday's UK-EU Summit in Brussels.

The numbers come from the Prosperity Institute, a think tank whose senior press officer, Joseph Dinnage, has published a stinging critique of the government's approach. His argument is simple: the deal the Prime Minister is selling as a cost-saver would actually make life more expensive, while the real lever for cheaper energy sits at home, in Westminster, not in Brussels.

What is Burnham actually proposing?

On Friday, Burnham travels to Brussels to launch what he calls a 'reset' of UK-EU relations — a plan Dinnage characterises as 'a thinly veiled plan to rejoin the bloc by stealth'. At the summit, the Prime Minister intends to sign new agreements on food, energy and youth mobility.

The energy component is the contentious one. The government wants to link the UK's ETS (emissions trading scheme — a market where polluters buy permits for each tonne of carbon they emit) with the EU's equivalent. British exporters would then escape payments into the EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, or CBAM (a charge the EU levies on carbon-intensive imports).

The government claims this linkage would save British exporters £800m, citing a 2024 Frontier Economics report. That report estimated UK businesses could otherwise pay £0.2–0.8bn into the EU budget as CBAM charges between 2026 and 2030, because UK carbon prices sit below EU levels.

Where does the £800m claim fall apart?

Dinnage calls the saving 'a fiction'. His point: the same Frontier Economics report shows the economy taking a £3.5–8bn hit from avoidable carbon taxes over the period. The claimed export saving is the smaller number; the damage estimate is up to ten times larger.

The mechanism behind the price rise matters. UK carbon permits are currently cheaper than EU ones. Link the two markets, and British prices drift up towards EU levels — hence the Prosperity Institute's calculation of a roughly 32 per cent increase. That cost flows through to industry, and from industry into consumer prices.

The political backdrop sharpened on Thursday night. Speaking at the Lord Mayor's banquet, Burnham declared: 'The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we have gained.' He said the time had come to discuss Britain's 'long-term relationship' with Brussels — while insisting the negotiations would not mean a return to the single market, the customs union, or freedom of movement. Dinnage's response is blunt: 'If you believe that, then I've got a bridge to sell you.' He notes that Burnham backed a second referendum on EU membership only a few years ago.

What would actually cut bills?

The Prosperity Institute's alternative is domestic abolition, not European integration. Its research recommends scrapping four measures:

  • the Climate Change Levy (a tax on business energy use);
  • Carbon Price Support (a top-up charge on fossil fuels used to generate electricity);
  • the UK ETS itself;
  • and the proposed UK CBAM.

The quantified payoff: energy users would see bills cut by £7.2bn a year. That works out at around £250 per household, including roughly £60 directly off household energy bills. The gross cost to the Exchequer would be £4.2bn, with a long-run GDP boost of up to £7.4bn — meaning the growth dividend alone could exceed the fiscal cost.

'Government-imposed taxes designed to force consumers to adopt renewable energy have made life much more expensive,' Dinnage writes, taking a swipe at what he calls 'Net Zero zealots like Miattah Fahnbulleh' along the way.

Is Brexit the problem?

The wider claim in the piece is political. Rejoining the EU, Dinnage argues, is routinely modelled by the Left as 'a silver bullet for solving Britain's problems', but the country's chronic issues 'have nothing to do with Brexit'. Cheaper energy, like growth or lower migration, requires domestic political will.

His verdict on turning to Brussels is unsparing: 'Turning to Brussels would be a cowardly, undemocratic and ultimately ineffective abdication of sovereignty.'

The challenge to Burnham is direct. The Prime Minister has pledged to give Britons 'breathing space' and promised he 'will not be squeamish' about fixing Britain's problems. If that pledge means anything, Dinnage concludes, it means taking bold decisions 'here at home, to make life more affordable for British citizens' — starting with the levies Westminster itself imposed, not a carbon-market deal negotiated in Brussels.

via cityam.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

459 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous articleNext article »

End of sheetSE-46 / N1 · November 18, 2026