Field report NW-24 / J5 · sheet /boards
Boards & GovernanceFiled from the territory
Nvidia's Board Faces Caremark Exposure Over Jensen Huang Oversight Failures
Nvidia has shed over $400 billion in market value since Jensen Huang's admission, and Delaware's Caremark doctrine now puts his board's oversight failures squarely in plaintiffs' lawyers' sights.
- Grid
- NW-24 / J5
- Surveyed
- November 17, 2026
- Reading
- 5 min read
- Correspondent
- Priya Raman

Field notes
- Nvidia stock closed at $168.89, down nearly 10% in two sessions — over $400 billion in market value lost — and about 30% below its early-October record.
- A Megaspeed affiliate bought about $4.8 billion of Nvidia-powered equipment in under two years; The Information reports companies tied to Alice Huang helped Chinese buyers obtain $7.5 billion in Nvidia chips.
- Boeing's comparable Caremark case settled for $237.5 million in 2021 after the 737 MAX crashes.
- Jensen Huang owns about 3.5% of Nvidia's single-class stock, has 50+ direct reports and no identified successor.
- Nvidia's trade compliance committee met three times last fiscal year; the company has no chief compliance officer.
By Priya Raman
Nvidia has lost more than $400 billion in market value in two trading sessions — and the deeper liability may land not on Jensen Huang, but on his board. Shareholder suits in Delaware Chancery Court, built on the Caremark oversight doctrine, are now a live possibility. The stock closed Tuesday at $168.89, down almost 10% since Huang admitted infidelity, and roughly 30% below its early-October record.
The sell-off was idiosyncratic, not sector-wide. On Monday, Nvidia fell 4.3% while the semiconductor index jumped nearly 7%, with direct competitors, including AMD, all rising.
How did we get here?
The timeline is damning. In October 2025, the New York Times reported that Megaspeed, a little-known Singapore firm, had bought billions of dollars of Nvidia chips amid suspicions it was laundering banned chips to China through neutral countries. Nvidia said an internal review found no evidence of diversion. In May 2026, short seller Culper Research alleged "uncomfortably close ties" between Megaspeed head Alice Huang and Jensen Huang.
Then, in late October 2026, the Times reported that U.S. intelligence believed Alice Huang was a Chinese asset. A company spokesperson called the diversion claims debunked and the relationship nothing unusual. Ten days later, Jensen Huang admitted he had been unfaithful to his wife, in a message that referenced the national security concerns in the press.
On Oct. 29, a company spokesman described the CEO's interactions with Alice Huang as "not unusual or unexpected." Nine days after that, Huang told employees about the affair.
What does the Caremark doctrine require?
The doctrine, established in 1996 in Delaware Chancery Court, holds that directors breach their duty of loyalty when they make no good-faith effort to monitor risks central to the business, or when they consciously ignore red flags. Precedents are stark:
- In 2019, Delaware's Supreme Court revived a suit against Blue Bell Creameries' directors, whose board had no food-safety oversight system before a deadly listeria outbreak.
- In 2021, the Court of Chancery let claims proceed against Boeing directors who had no board committee responsible for airplane safety before the 737 MAX crashes. That case settled for $237.5 million.
The lesson: on existential risks, the board must watch for itself. It cannot simply trust management.
What questions should directors have asked?
Plaintiffs' lawyers will ask what the board didn't. Who ran the review that cleared Megaspeed? Did it report to independent directors or to management? Did any director know the CEO had a personal relationship with an executive at the customer under review?
The answers sit in board minutes — and shareholders can get them. Nvidia fought a books-and-records demand to Delaware's Supreme Court in 2022 and lost. Even after Delaware narrowed inspection rights, minutes remain reachable. That's how Boeing plaintiffs built their case.
The conflict at the center is sizeable. A Megaspeed affiliate bought about $4.8 billion of Nvidia-powered equipment in under two years, and Nvidia's own code of conduct would likely have required disclosure of a CEO's personal tie to a customer that size. By October 2025, both Washington and Singapore were investigating Megaspeed.
The compliance posture invites scrutiny too. Per Bloomberg, Nvidia's general counsel contacted a senior Commerce Department official about the government's Megaspeed probe. Did the board authorize that call? Did it even know? Nvidia's proxy shows the board committee responsible for trade compliance met three times last fiscal year, and the company has no chief compliance officer.
How big is the national security problem?
The Information reported that companies tied to Alice Huang helped Chinese buyers obtain $7.5 billion of Nvidia chips, including banned ones laundered through neutral parties. The report is unconfirmed; Megaspeed denies wrongdoing.
The Times further reported that U.S. officials concluded Alice Huang was recruited by China's Ministry of State Security to get close to Jensen and shape his views on chip sales to China — on which he has been vocal, arguing the U.S. should keep selling to China. No one has alleged Jensen knew; Beijing calls the claims a smear. But the president was reportedly briefed in late 2025, a secret memo circulated this spring, three House committee chairmen want Huang in a closed-door briefing, and the president says the FBI is reviewing the matter. Not one Nvidia director, as Semafor noted, has a national security background.
Export violations carry penalties from fines to criminal prosecution to loss of export privileges. Boards shouldn't wait for verdicts before asking questions.
Why didn't governance safeguards catch this?
Here's the twist. Nvidia has no dual-class shares — a single class of common stock. Huang owns about 3.5% and casts 3.5% of the votes. The board is declassified, every director stands annually, and a simple majority could replace him at any meeting. On paper, he's as removable as any hired manager.
In practice, no CEO in America has been more immune from scrutiny. What entrenched Huang wasn't the capital structure; it was board deference — what the Fortune authors call idolatry. Nvidia has the independent majority, lead director, annual elections and single share class that ISS and Glass Lewis reward. Enron, Tyco, Wells Fargo and Boeing all had one share, one vote too.
Succession compounds the failure. Huang has more than 50 direct reports and no identified successor; one prominent analyst estimates Nvidia would be worth 25% to 30% less without him.
Even now, the reflex is deference. The same statement that launched the board's investigation declared, before a single interview, that the board had "no reason to believe that either national security or Nvidia secrets were compromised." A board announcing its conclusion the day it opens an inquiry suggests the outcome may be predetermined.
If Delaware Caremark claims come, the court will ask what the board knew and what it did to find out. Failing to question a celebrated CEO about a customer under federal investigation, the authors argue, is no business judgment at all. Nvidia's directors were paid to provide oversight, however brilliant the man they oversaw. By all outside appearances, they whiffed.
via fortune.com/feed/ (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
459 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Nvidia Has Lost $450 Billion as Board Moves to Oust Jensen Huang
- Nvidia Loses $400 Billion in Two Days as Huang Scandal Meets China Chip Claims
- Nvidia Board Rules Out Jensen Huang's Return as CEO
- Nvidia Loses $192bn in Market Value Over CEO Espionage Allegations
- Nvidia and Jensen Huang Sued by Shareholders After $190bn Wipeout