Field report E-23 / J4 · sheet /macro

Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory

Not an attack: US officials 98% sure outages weren't foreign sabotage

US officials are 98% confident last week's FAA, Microsoft and bank outages weren't foreign attacks. Ex-CISA chief Bridget Bean explains why patches, glitches and sabotage look identical at first.

Grid
E-23 / J4
Surveyed
November 19, 2026
Reading
4 min read
Correspondent
Priya Raman
Outage or attack? In the moment, they can look the same
Fig. E-23 / J4Outage or attack? In the moment, they can look the same — Akela999 / pixabay

Field notes

  1. DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin said Wednesday he is 98% confident the outages were not caused by foreign adversaries.
  2. The FAA grounded domestic flights last Friday; Microsoft and multiple banks also suffered outages last week.
  3. Ex-CISA acting director Bridget Bean said an attack, a patch, or a glitch can all look the same during an incident.
  4. Bean said AI lets attackers launch campaigns that once took weeks or months in a single afternoon.
  5. Some critical U.S. systems have not been upgraded for decades, compounding technical debt.

America's top security officials have concluded, with 98% confidence, that last week's wave of connectivity disruptions was not a coordinated foreign attack — and the woman who once ran the country's cyber defense agency says that uncertainty is exactly what the moment demands.

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin told lawmakers at a House Intelligence Committee hearing on Wednesday that he was "98% confident that this has nothing to do" with foreign adversaries. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton, who also appeared before the committee, affirmed the same working assessment.

The disruptions cut across sectors. The Federal Aviation Administration grounded domestic flights last Friday. Microsoft suffered an outage last week. Multiple banks reported problems. Different failures, one common thread: the same old technology underpinning all of them.

Why an outage and an attack look identical at first

Bridget Bean, former acting director of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA, the federal body that defends civilian networks and critical infrastructure), knows the view from inside the room. She spoke to Pentagon Posture about what officials actually face when systems go dark.

"I've been in the room when these things are happening, and you're dealing with a number of things at one time," she said. "You're trying to figure out what's happening. You're trying to make sure your continuity of operation plans is still in. You're trying to see what else could be impacted next."

Her bottom line: "An attack, a patch, or a glitch can all look the same."

Bean offers a plain-language analogy. Compare U.S. technological infrastructure to a phone. When a user agrees to a software upgrade, the device often goes offline briefly, glitches need working out, some apps need redownloading. Translation: when the United States finds a vulnerability and fixes it, the repair may require taking systems offline — and can trigger unintended consequences.

During her tenure at CISA, Bean said, the agency tracked outages it initially believed were nation-state attacks that turned out not to be. The opposite happened too — incidents first dismissed as glitches later proved hostile.

Patching, technical debt and the daily siege

The mechanism behind last week's failures is mundane but relentless. "Nation-state actors and criminals are trying to break into our systems every day," Bean said. "We're constantly patching to stay ahead of them, and sometimes those fixes break things. And much of our infrastructure is old, and so we're carrying all that huge technical debt."

She served as CISA's acting director at the start of the second Trump administration, after holding other roles at the agency.

What should the administration tell the public?

Several lawmakers have criticized the administration's lack of transparency since the FAA closed domestic airspace. Bean pushes back on the silence, not the substance.

"What I would like to see, and I think we're seeing more of it, is a transparency to the people. Americans are smart; they deserve to be told the truth, and they can handle bad news," she said. "I think the American people can live with some uncertainty. What I don't think that they can tolerate is the feeling like they weren't getting the whole truth, and that's a communication style."

She wants the administration and Congress to treat this as an education opportunity — teaching the public about critical infrastructure, its vulnerabilities, and personal precautions. The entry-level threats are surprisingly low-tech.

"Cybercriminals and nation-state actors — a lot of what they do does not require sophisticated cyber technology," Bean said. "They're logging in through weak passwords; they're logging in through the open internet on things that people don't know are open. People are still clicking on things. They're not updating their software."

Does AI make this better or worse?

Both, and faster. Experts can use artificial intelligence to identify and resolve vulnerabilities before attackers strike. Nefarious actors can harness the same tools to exploit them.

"Our world is much more connected, and I think that AI is accelerating all of it exponentially," Bean said. "The attackers are using AI to find vulnerabilities and to launch campaigns that used to take weeks or months, and now they can do it… literally in an afternoon."

Some systems underpinning the U.S. way of life haven't been upgraded in decades, which compounds the problem as AI usage grows. Bean sees no alternative to fighting fire with fire.

"Lots of things can be true at the same time, but I think there is a real need to use AI to defend our critical systems," she said. "I believe we can do it. I believe we prioritize them."

via washingtonexaminer.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

464 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous article

End of sheetE-23 / J4 · November 19, 2026