Field report N-35 / P1 · sheet /operations

Operations & RestructuringFiled from the territory

Ex-FEMA Chief Says Bureaucrats, Not L3Harris, Caused FAA Grounding

Roughly 12,000 flights were halted in the second nationwide FAA stoppage since 9/11. Ex-FEMA chief Richardson says Duffy's blame on L3Harris hides the real failure inside the federal ranks.

Grid
N-35 / P1
Surveyed
November 16, 2026
Reading
5 min read
Correspondent
Sophie Lindqvist
Flight, fiasco, and finger-pointing
Fig. N-35 / P1Flight, fiasco, and finger-pointing — JESHOOTS-com / pixabay

Field notes

  1. About 12,000 flights were grounded or canceled; the FAA halted all departures for over four hours with roughly 3,500 aircraft aloft — the second nationwide stoppage since 9/11.
  2. The failure is traced to a radar site where L3Harris was installing a new router; cause and FAA sign-off status remain undetermined.
  3. Duffy said of L3Harris: 'They own this network... I can't go somewhere else.'
  4. The FAA awarded Verizon a $2.4 billion replacement contract in 2023, then put AT&T in the lead this August without a new competition.
  5. The modernization estimate jumped from $30 billion to $50 billion after the failure; the FAA had obligated only $1.8 billion of $9 billion in modernization funds by March.

Roughly 12,000 flights were grounded or canceled nationwide last weekend after the Federal Aviation Administration (the US regulator of civil aviation) halted every departure for more than four hours late Friday afternoon, with about 3,500 aircraft already in the air. It was only the second such nationwide stoppage since September 11, 2001. Now a former senior federal official is arguing that the Transportation Secretary's blame on the contractor L3Harris misses the real failure inside government itself.

David Richardson, who served as a senior official performing the duties of FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency) administrator and previously ran the Department of Homeland Security's Countering Weapons of Mass Destruction Office, makes that case in a sharply worded op-ed. His core claim: political appointees do not run federal agencies — the career bureaucracy runs them.

What happened on Friday?

The FAA says its legacy equipment went unstable when data flooded the network. The initial investigation points to a radar site where L3Harris, a defense and aerospace contractor, was installing a new router.

What is not said matters just as much, Richardson notes. Nobody has established whether the failure was operator error, installation error, or a defective unit. Nobody has said whether the FAA signed off on the work.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy moved quickly to assign responsibility. "They own this network," he said of L3Harris. "They're our prime contractor. I can't go somewhere else." He has also said many contractors "take our money and provide really poor service."

Is the contractor really at fault?

Richardson's answer is skeptical. The FAA, he argues, is mandated to oversee its contractors, and blaming them is abdication. He cites precedent: in January 2023, the FAA blamed "contract personnel" who "unintentionally deleted files" for a similar breakdown.

Either Duffy does not understand the oversight mandate because federal employees are whispering deflections in his ear, Richardson writes, or he prefers not to alienate the federal machine. In both scenarios, career officials — not the president's appointee — are calling the shots.

The acquisition backdrop complicates the picture further:

  • L3Harris and its predecessor, Harris, have run the FAA's telecommunications network since 2002.
  • The FAA awarded Verizon a $2.4 billion contract in 2023 to replace that network.
  • This August, the agency put AT&T in the lead instead — without a new competition — saying the old network "can no longer support" air traffic operations.

Richardson calls the sequence confusing, and it is hard to argue. Two competing carriers, one $2.4 billion award, and a lead swapped midstream without a fresh competition invite questions the FAA has not yet answered publicly.

What does this change for taxpayers?

When incidents like this occur, Richardson argues, the reflexive call is always for more money. The evidence he assembles is blunt:

  • The modernization fix was priced at $30 billion before the failure; by Saturday morning after the grounding, the figure being discussed was $50 billion.
  • Congress gave the FAA $12.5 billion in July 2025.
  • By March, the Government Accountability Office reported the FAA had obligated only $1.8 billion of the $9 billion designated for modernizing systems.

Money, in other words, was already appropriated and largely unspent. What does this change for the flying public? On Richardson's reading, nothing — until someone inside the agency accepts responsibility rather than requesting larger appropriations. He adds that the spending feeds a $40 trillion national debt he describes as a burden that "will turn our children into serfs."

A pattern the author claims to have broken

Richardson supports his argument with his own record. He says he shut down CWMD, which is closed today, after a review found its mission could be done by fewer than 100 federal employees rather than the 500 assigned. Around 150 former CWMD personnel, he writes, still float around DHS doing the old mission.

He extends the critique to FEMA, where he says the agency believes its mission is helping people — a belief he claims has no basis in law. Mission creep, he argues, has turned it into a nationwide social services operation staffed by upwards of 18,000 people, versus roughly 4,000 in 2006.

His FEMA transformation stalled, in his telling, because the FEMA Review Council took a year to orient itself and make a recommendation to President Donald Trump. "Opportunity lost," he writes.

The uncomfortable caveat

Richardson's diagnosis carries a caveat worth holding onto: this is one official's account, from a self-described outsider proud of having dismantled two agencies. His claim that Duffy — a former congressman and, Richardson notes with some relish, a competitive lumberjack who raced up an 80-foot pole at the Lumberjack World Championships — has been captured by his own workforce is an assertion, not a finding.

The official investigation has not concluded. Until it establishes whether the failure was human error, a bad router, or missing FAA sign-off, the attribution of blame remains exactly what Richardson accuses everyone of: politics.

His warning, though, is specific. Blaming contractors takes the heat off but does not remove the problem, he writes. The problem, in his view, is in the ranks — and those who know it, he argues, will not tell Duffy, because keeping their job matters more to them than the safety of the American people. That is a serious charge from someone who once held comparable responsibility. It deserves an answer more detailed than a finger pointed at a vendor.

via washingtonexaminer.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

483 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous articleNext article »

End of sheetN-35 / P1 · November 16, 2026