Field report E-19 / J9 · sheet /macro
Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory
Visa-Mastercard fee deal awaits final approval after 1,000+ objections
Brooklyn federal judge Cogan withheld final approval of Visa and Mastercard's swipe-fee settlement after more than 1,000 objections, despite projected merchant savings of $38 billion by 2031.
- Grid
- E-19 / J9
- Surveyed
- November 20, 2026
- Reading
- 3 min read
- Correspondent
- Elena Vasquez

Field notes
- The settlement is projected to save merchants $38 billion by 2031 as part of $224 billion in total estimated benefits.
- Visa and Mastercard swipe fees totaled $118.8 billion across the United States in 2025, at an average rate of 2.36%.
- The proposal cuts interchange by 0.10 of a percentage point for five years and caps standard consumer-card charges at 1.25% for eight years.
- The court logged more than 1,000 objections, with estimates of affected businesses ranging from over 12 million to more than 20 million.
- A different judge rejected an earlier $30 billion settlement in June 2024.
By Elena Vasquez
A federal judge in Brooklyn withheld final approval after Monday’s hearing on a Visa and Mastercard swipe-fee settlement that plaintiffs’ experts estimate will save merchants $38 billion by 2031, despite more than 1,000 objections.
Judge Cogan said turning down the deal could set off a protracted process if the case proceeds to trial, according to Reuters.
The dispute concerns interchange fees charged on card payments. The Merchants Payments Coalition reported that Visa and Mastercard collected $118.8 billion in swipe fees across the United States in 2025, at an average rate of 2.36%. The proposed 1.25% ceiling for standard consumer cards would sit below that average, though the two measures cover different card categories.
Visa lawyer Michael Shuster called the proposal “potent” relief for merchants while acknowledging Visa was hardly “jumping with joy.” He said: “It’s going to change life for the networks.”
What does the settlement change?
The agreement would require Visa and Mastercard to reduce interchange fees by 0.10 of a percentage point for five years. It would limit charges on standard consumer cards to 1.25% for eight years.
The settlement would end the “Honor All Cards” rule, which requires a merchant to accept every card on a network or reject that network entirely. For the first time, merchants could select one of three categories:
- Standard consumer cards.
- Commercial cards.
- Premium consumer cards, including rewards cards.
The proposed settlement would apply to more than 12 million merchants, although opponents put the number of affected businesses at more than 20 million.
Why do merchants still oppose the deal?
The court logged just over 1,000 objections, including filings from Walmart and the National Retail Federation. Some opponents argue that merchants would continue paying steep fees on rewards cards and would still lack the ability to choose among issuers, such as accepting one bank’s cards while turning away another’s.
Mithun Mansinghani, a lawyer for the National Association of Convenience Stores and Circle K, told Cogan that the settlement contained no structural changes that would foster real competition among card issuers.
He said excessive charges on commercial and premium consumer cards would persist; together, those segments account for more than 90% of the card market. “Competition should be the North Star ... and this settlement is way off course,” Mansinghani said, according to Reuters.
What is the financial prize?
Plaintiffs retained economist Joseph Stiglitz and Keith Leffler, a University of Washington professor, as experts. They estimated that the changes could deliver $224 billion in total benefits, including for consumers, with merchants saving $38 billion by 2031. The merchant estimate accounts for about 17% of the experts’ broader $224 billion projection.
That projection sits against $118.8 billion in U.S. interchange fees generated by the two networks in 2025. The comparison is not like for like: one measure concerns projected benefits, while the other reports fees paid in a single year.
What did the court decide before?
Cogan granted preliminary approval in June and said he expected to grant final approval. He described the terms as fair, reasonable and adequate, while acknowledging that some objections raised legitimate points and saying perfection was not the required standard.
In June 2024, a different judge, Margo Brodie, refused to approve an earlier $30 billion settlement because she considered its size inadequate. Brodie concluded that swipe fees would not have fallen to pre-violation levels and that the Honor All Cards obligation would have remained intact.
The revised agreement adds a five-year fee cut, an eight-year 1.25% standard-card cap and an end to mandatory acceptance across all card categories.
For merchants, Cogan’s pending decision will determine whether projected $38 billion in 2031 savings outweigh more than 1,000 objections over fees and competition.
via qz.com (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
537 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Visa and Mastercard Ask Court to Close $38 Billion Fee Saga
- NPCI caps B2B UPI merchant fees at flat ₹5 per transfer
- NPCI notified UPI Vyapaar Saksham on 11 November 2026: a 5% MDR levy recycled into small-merchant incentives
- ₹5 UPI fee proposed for business payments; launch date still absent
- Mastercard and Glyde Bring Virtual Card Payments to Southern African Travel