Field report S-45 / P8 · sheet /macro
Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory
Trump can fight state data center bans with existing federal law
- Grid
- S-45 / P8
- Surveyed
- November 17, 2026
- Reading
- 3 min read
- Correspondent
- Priya Raman

Trump should use existing federal powers to defend strategically important data centers before state freezes harden, because the Defense Production Act’s principal authorities expire Dec. 11 unless Congress renews them.
Colton Overcash, founder of Charlotte-based government relations and strategic advisory firm Vertex Strategies, argues that another executive order promising faster permits would do less than existing law. His recommendation is blunt: “Trump does not need another Congress to give him those powers. He needs to order his administration to use them.”
What is the political threat?
Political opposition now poses a risk beyond slow permits or difficult utility negotiations. Opponents seek outright construction restrictions, while Democratic victories in Congress and several state governments have raised the prospect of broader moratoria (temporary development bans).
Trump can veto legislation imposing a nationwide freeze, but not governors and local officials who can obstruct billions of dollars in investment without bringing disputes to Washington.
How should Washington define the federal stake?
Trump’s May 2025 executive order directs the Energy Department to consider designating artificial intelligence (AI) data centers at, or operated with, its facilities as critical defense facilities (sites essential to defense missions), even outside government installations.
The Pentagon, Energy Department and other national security agencies should identify essential computing capacity and secure it through procurement and contracting authorities (government purchasing and private-supplier agreements) before restrictions threaten construction.
Three federal selections show the mechanism. The Army conditionally selected Carlyle and CyrusOne to negotiate hyperscale (very large-scale) developments at Fort Bliss in Texas and Dugway Proving Ground in Utah.
At South Carolina’s Savannah River Site, the National Nuclear Security Administration selected Amentum to negotiate a 1-gigawatt data center supported by approximately 2 gigawatts of on-site generation. The arrangement links federal missions with private development and gives projects legal significance beyond ordinary construction.
Can federal law displace state bans?
In 2022, the 9th Circuit ruled in GEO Group v. Newsom that California could not use its ban on private detention facilities to override Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s lawful reliance on private contractors. Federal courts have already limited state interference with authorized government operations.
Overcash’s legal argument is that when Congress authorizes a federal mission, a state cannot necessarily dictate how the government uses private contractors. A moratorium blocking capacity required for an authorized defense or intelligence operation could face a federal challenge. Documenting requirements early gives the Justice Department a concrete interest to defend.
What does the Defense Production Act add?
In the Sable Offshore dispute, the Energy Department ordered the company to restart a California oil pipeline under federal allocation authority in March. California officials resisted; in August, a federal judge ruled that the state parks department could not prevent compliance.
The ruling remains under appeal. It nevertheless shows that an order directed at private infrastructure can overcome state resistance, a precedent for challenging moratoria that obstruct a documented federal mission.
The Defense Production Act could also prioritize qualifying contracts for scarce electrical equipment and support domestic manufacturing capacity. Existing law preserves performance of valid commitments entered before expiry.
Can telecom and energy law help?
Federal telecommunications law offers another route without declaring an emergency. Section 253 of the Communications Act prohibits state and local measures that effectively block covered telecommunications services (a defined category of communications infrastructure).
The Federal Communications Commission’s 2018 Moratoria Order protected telecommunications deployment from restrictions, and the 9th Circuit upheld it in 2020. A provider could
via washingtonexaminer.com (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
459 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Selloff in AI chips after Democratic win tests political risk math
- Data Center Backlash Has an Overlooked Driver: The Buildings Are Ugly
- Data center backlash forces a new playbook for AI builders
- Midterm Voters Rejected Data Centers. A Clean Energy Standard Is the Answer, Climate Advisers Says
- Voters in 10 States Back Data Center Curbs. Now What?