Field report W-39 / M1 · sheet /macro
Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory
Ten Indicators and One Verdict: The Framework That Called Both Fed Cycles
Nine of ten indicators flagged Fed tightening in March 2022; by August 2024 six signalled easing. The framework caught both cycles — with caveats.
- Grid
- W-39 / M1
- Surveyed
- November 16, 2026
- Reading
- 3 min read
- Correspondent
- Sophie Lindqvist

Field notes
- Nine of ten indicators signalled tightening in March 2022; the Fed then hiked +525 bps.
- Six of ten indicators signalled easing in August 2024; the Fed then cut −175 bps.
- Futures implied ~7.2 hikes in March 2022 and ~8.7 cuts in August 2024 over 15 months.
- The March 2022 Taylor Rule gap was −1,204 bps against a −70 bps historical median.
- Brent crude was up +71.8% YoY in March 2022 but down −13.5% YoY in August 2024.
Nine out of ten quantitative indicators signalled that the Federal Reserve should tighten policy in March 2022; fifteen months later, the central bank had delivered +525 basis points of rate hikes. By August 2024, six of the same ten indicators had flipped to easing, and the Fed went on to cut by −175 bps. Those are the headline results of a framework published by the analyst QuantitativeAlpha on TradingView, which benchmarks ten market and macroeconomic gauges against their historical behaviour when inflation, measured by the Trimmed Mean PCE rate (a core inflation gauge that strips extreme price moves), sat between 2% and 2.5%.
The method is simple in outline. Nine indicators are compared against their historical interquartile ranges — the band between the 25th and 75th percentile of past readings. A reading far enough from the historical median to fall outside that band signals tightening or easing. A reading inside the band signals holding rates unchanged. The tenth indicator reads the market's own expectations directly.
What did the framework show in March 2022?
The readings were almost unanimous, and uniformly extreme.
- Fed Treasury holdings grew at +18.5% year-on-year against a +4.6% median, signalling tightening (shrinking the Fed's balance sheet pushes more Treasuries onto the private market and raises borrowing costs).
- The 2-year Treasury minus the Fed funds rate spread stood at +123 bps, far above the +44 bps median — markets expected higher short-term rates.
- The Fed funds rate minus the Taylor Rule (a formula prescribing policy from inflation and the output gap) sat at −1,204 bps versus a −70 bps median: policy was drastically looser than the rule prescribed.
- Bank loans and leases grew +5.7% YoY against a +7.6% median — the lone "hold" signal.
- M2 money supply grew +10.6% YoY against a +5.0% median.
- Unemployment (U3) minus NAIRU (the jobless rate below which inflation accelerates) was −54 bps versus a +23 bps median: a tight labour market.
- Hourly wage growth minus productivity growth hit +791 bps against a +144 bps median, flagging wage-driven inflation.
- Brent crude rose +71.8% YoY against a +10.5% median.
- The 10-year breakeven inflation rate (the gap between nominal and inflation-indexed Treasury yields) was 2.6% versus a 2.3% median.
The tenth indicator, based on 30-Day Federal Funds Futures (contracts priced at 100 minus the implied average Fed funds rate), implied +181 bps of tightening over the following 15 months — roughly 7.2 hikes. The Fed delivered more.
How had the picture changed by August 2024?
Six indicators had flipped to easing; four signalled holding. Fed Treasury holdings were contracting at −12.1% YoY. The 2-year spread had swung to −142 bps. Bank credit growth had slowed to +2.4%, M2 growth to +2.0%, and Brent crude was falling at −13.5% YoY.
The hold signals deserve attention, because they say what the easing narrative leaves out. The Taylor Rule gap had narrowed to +1 bp — policy was neither loose nor tight by the rule. Unemployment was 22 bps below NAIRU, still a tight labour market. The wage-productivity gap, at +128 bps, was within its historical band, and the 10-year breakeven rate of 2.2% was close to the 2.3% median. In other words, four of ten gauges saw no case for cuts at all.
Futures, for their part, implied −217 bps of easing over 15 months — approximately 8.7 cuts. The Fed has since cut less than half of that.
What does this change for investors?
The framework's value is systematic rather than predictive precision: futures overshot the hiking cycle by roughly 200 bps and have so far overshot the cutting cycle by an even wider margin. The author concedes the point directly, noting that "historical relationships and market-implied expectations evolve as economic conditions, inflation dynamics, and Federal Reserve policy responses change over time."
That caveat is the honest one. A dashboard calibrated on a 2–2.5% inflation regime may misread an economy that no longer resembles it. Nine indicators pointing one way is a strong signal; it is not a promise.
via tradingview.com (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
469 articles