Field report SE-34 / Q3 · sheet /deals

M&A & DealsFiled from the territory

Private equity retreats as UK retail debts and scrutiny mount

Modella Capital seeks an exit from TG Jones after 18 months, while Poundland scrutiny and £7.5bn Morrisons debt expose the strains facing private equity in British retail.

Grid
SE-34 / Q3
Surveyed
November 18, 2026
Reading
4 min read
Correspondent
Amara Osei
How private equity’s retail shopping spree went wrong
Fig. SE-34 / Q3How private equity’s retail shopping spree went wrong — cherry19921025 / pixabay

Field notes

  1. Modella Capital is seeking an exit from TG Jones 18 months after ending WH Smith’s 233-year high-street run.
  2. TG Jones has shed about 150 stores through its restructuring and rebranding from WH Smith.
  3. Gordon Brothers bought Poundland last year and refused solvent offers amid a dispute involving a £30m loan.
  4. Morrisons’ net debt rose from £7.1bn to £7.5bn in 2025 after CD&R acquired the retailer in 2021.
  5. Asda, owned by TDR Capital, remains burdened by more than £3bn of debt despite a reduction.

By Amara Osei

London-based Modella Capital is seeking an exit from TG Jones only 18 months after ending WH Smith’s 233-year run on the British high street, meaning the country’s main shopping streets. The heritage chain, rebranded from WH Smith, has shed about 150 stores through a severe restructuring, leaving what sources close to Modella describe as a smaller but viable business.

Modella’s retreat follows its recent oversight of the collapses of Claire’s Accessories and The Original Factory Shop. The TG Jones restructuring has also triggered landlord backlash over proposed rent cuts and local complaints about the loss of Post Offices.

Why is private equity retreating from the high street?

Private equity investors (funds that acquire and own unlisted companies) have acquired Poundland, TG Jones and Morrisons during the past five years. Gordon Brothers, a US investment firm, bought Poundland only last year, then faced intense scrutiny over its sale after refusing solvent offers amid a row over a £30m loan.

The grocery sector shows comparable strain:

  • Morrisons: New York-based CD&R bought the chain in 2021. Its net debt (borrowings less cash) rose from £7.1bn to £7.5bn in 2025.
  • Asda: TDR Capital owns the retailer, whose debt has fallen but remains above £3bn.

Both chains face pressure from family-owned Lidl and Aldi in the discount segment. Tesco and Sainsbury’s, both publicly held, dominate the upper end of the market.

What makes a worthwhile retail return difficult?

City analysts and advisers said private equity owners bought many assets cheaply, but turning those purchases into a worthwhile return from British high-street assets remains difficult. Nalin Patel, director of private capital research at Pitchbook, said the “challenging environment for retail is likely to deter” future private equity investors from seeking UK high-street assets.

Rising business rates, falling consumer confidence and a shift in demand toward e-commerce (online shopping) make technology, energy infrastructure and finance more attractive to private investors, Patel said. He said private equity funds need businesses that consistently increase revenue and ultimately margins over time.

Jonny Bethell, a private equity adviser at Winston Taylor, said few specialist buyers show interest because UK retail has remained in a macroeconomic downturn (a broad fall in activity) for some time. He called the opportunities anything but slam-dunk investments and said pressure on TG Jones and Poundland has persuaded others that avoiding them is the right decision.

He also said criticism can be unfair because private equity houses have taken a chance by investing capital in businesses already on a downturn to turn them around. Negative publicity can also damage the investment firm, he added, making the sector less attractive to new capital.

What does the Poundland dispute reveal?

On Wednesday last week, Mark Newton-Jones, a Gordon Brothers executive, appeared before Parliament’s Business Select Committee. Committee chair Liam Byrne said the firm was “jeopardising thousands of jobs on Britain’s high streets” and had seen “concerning signs” that Poundland had been “estranged of access to its own funds.”

Andy Burnham called on Gordon Brothers to explain why it had not secured a deal for the retailer. Reform UK treasury spokesperson Robert Jenrick branded the firm a corporate raider.

A City advisory executive said nobody relished appearing before Liam Byrne with rockets thrown at the witness. Rising costs and slumping consumer confidence were causing chaos and carnage for retailers up and down the country, the executive added. The same executive said private equity still has a role in acquiring struggling high-street businesses because no obvious alternative buyer exists.

Will political scrutiny deter overseas buyers?

Another City adviser said British public skepticism toward overseas private equity owners now deters purchases of UK high-street businesses. The adviser described anti-consumerism, anti-capitalism and anti-Americanism as cross-party themes, particularly prominent in Labour. He said US ownership of high-street assets had become a common concern among British policymakers and the public.

What must owners and investors do next?

Modella believes TG Jones would perform better under an experienced retailer capable of completing the turnaround. The Poundland sale remains entangled with the £30m loan dispute, leaving Gordon Brothers under sustained political and financial pressure.

Asda’s debt has fallen but remains above £3bn; Morrisons’ net debt rose to £7.5bn in 2025. Patel said funds need businesses that consistently increase revenue and ultimately margins over time. Bethell said few specialist buyers show interest while UK retail remains in a macroeconomic downturn.

via cityam.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

449 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous articleNext article »

End of sheetSE-34 / Q3 · November 18, 2026