Field report N-87 / M2 · sheet /operations
Operations & RestructuringFiled from the territory
Premier's Tulbagh cannery closure leaves peach growers R32,500 per hectare short
Premier's R3,250-per-tonne settlement leaves Tulbagh peach growers an estimated R32,500 per hectare short of costs as the harvest starts early and contractual rights remain in dispute.
- Grid
- N-87 / M2
- Surveyed
- November 19, 2026
- Reading
- 3 min read
- Correspondent
- Olivia Hart

Field notes
- Proposed settlement of R3,250 per tonne equals R123,500 per hectare at the 38-tonne benchmark yield
- Growers say they have already incurred about R156,000 per hectare — a R32,500 per hectare shortfall
- Premier reports agreements with 82 farmers covering over 20,000 tonnes and R67 million in payments
- Picking began in Calitzdorp on 9 November; Robertson deliveries started eight days earlier than last year
- Premier declined to extend arbitration-based delivery terms beyond the five court applicants
Peach growers contracted to Premier's Tulbagh cannery face a cash settlement they say falls an estimated R32,500 per hectare short of the production costs they have already incurred. The dispute has reached the courts just as the harvest begins, leaving farmers with ripening fruit and no confirmed buyer.
What does the settlement offer?
Premier says it has reached agreements with 82 farmers covering more than 20,000 tonnes of peaches and R67 million in payments. The proposed cash settlement works out at R3,250 per tonne.
At the industry benchmark yield of 38 tonnes per hectare, that amounts to R123,500 per hectare. Growers estimate they have already incurred 70% of their annual production costs — about R156,000 per hectare at benchmark costs. That gap of roughly R32,500 per hectare sits at the centre of the standoff between the company and the grower organisations.
Why is timing critical for growers?
The harvest season is already under way, and the calendar is working against the farmers. Some growers report apricots ripening up to two weeks earlier than usual. Picking began in Calitzdorp on 9 November, and the first deliveries in the Robertson area started eight days earlier than last year.
Affected growers say they were still waiting for individual written agreements when harvesting began. The pressure of a compressed season gives them almost no room to negotiate or find alternative processing capacity.
"Breaking even on investments in orchards take years. Once the fruit ripens, growers have only days to harvest and deliver it," says Johann Kotzé, Chief Executive Officer of AgriSA.
What is the contractual dispute about?
The Cannery Fruit Producers' Association (CFPA) says the three options Premier presented to growers required them to surrender rights and settle claims under their supply agreements. Growers who signed would give up the ability to pursue the contractual dispute further.
In court, Premier offered a narrower arrangement: it would receive, grade, transport and pay for the fruit of the five applicants while preserving their contractual rights. That offer came with conditions — an arbitration process and a separate undertaking covering potential losses.
Premier declined the CFPA's request to extend that arbitration process to other affected growers.
What do the grower bodies want?
AgriSA, Agri Western Cape and the CFPA are pressing Premier to extend the proposed court arrangement beyond the five applicants. Their ask is specific: let all affected growers deliver their contracted fruit while retaining their rights to pursue the contractual dispute through arbitration, as provided for in their original agreements.
For growers, the distinction matters because the orchard investment cycle runs over years, not seasons. Accepting a settlement that surrenders contractual rights would close off arbitration as a route to recovering the cost gap — a risk the grower bodies are unwilling to accept while fruit sits ripe in the orchard.
The immediate question is mechanical: who receives, grades and pays for the tonnes now coming off the trees. Picking started in Calitzdorp on 9 November and deliveries in Robertson eight days ahead of last year, yet many growers still hold no written agreement covering their fruit.
via bizcommunity.com (Source)
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
458 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Asda's food sales growth stalls at 0.1% as new CEO takes charge
- Fuller's Pre-Tax Profit Jumps to £28.5m on Jubel and Asahi Demand
- Mamdani Says Trump Secured 90-Day SNAP Extension for Small Businesses
- Once Upon a Farm Cuts Outlook Up to $45 Million on Recall
- Asda hunts takeover targets as UK retail dealmaking revives