Field report NE-40 / N8 · sheet /macro
Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory
Milburn Report Warns Labour: Its Own Policies Fuel NEET Crisis
Milburn's final report says a third of employers plan fewer permanent hires. Helen Whately argues Labour is ignoring every warning on business costs while signing up only to spending.
- Grid
- NE-40 / N8
- Surveyed
- November 18, 2026
- Reading
- 4 min read
- Correspondent
- Sophie Lindqvist

Field notes
- Nearly 1 million NEETs in the UK, per Milburn's final report published yesterday
- More than a third of employers plan to hire fewer permanent staff, the review finds
- Tory plan: halve employer NI for under-25s, worth £1,500 a year per National Living Wage hire
- Conservatives pledge £36 billion of welfare savings and a 'Get to Work' claimant plan
- Milburn's interim report appeared in May; government accepted only spending recommendations
Nearly one million young people in the UK are not in education, employment or training — the group known as NEETs — and Alan Milburn's final report on youth worklessness, published yesterday, puts part of the blame squarely on Labour's own tax and regulatory agenda. The government's response, according to shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately, has been to ignore every line of it that implicates business policy.
The charge is serious, and the numbers behind it are worth examining before accepting the government's silence at face value.
What has actually hit employers?
Milburn's review documents a stack of cumulative cost increases that Whately enumerates in a piece for City A.M.:
- National Insurance contributions for employers raised
- Inflation-busting increases in minimum wage costs
- Business rates up
- The Employment Rights Act, which Whately describes as containing "job-killing policies on page after page"
The review's most quotable statistic: more than a third of employers now plan to hire fewer permanent staff as a result of these measures. That is a forward-looking intention, not a measured outcome — employers may adjust plans if conditions change. Still, it is the clearest signal yet that hiring appetite among firms is deteriorating.
What did Milburn actually say?
The former Labour health secretary, whose report carries weight precisely because it comes from within his own party's tradition, made two pointed warnings. "There is nothing progressive about pricing young people out of work," he writes. He goes further, warning that government "cannot be indifferent to the cumulative effect of the costs and obligations it places on the decision to hire."
He also cautions that the youth labour market must not be "flooded with more new regulation" — a line Whately suggests ministers should pin above every desk in Whitehall. Her assessment is blunt on the record since: indifference is exactly what has been delivered, Budget after Budget.
How did the government respond?
Here the story turns from analysis to politics. Responding in Parliament, the welfare secretary ignored every passage in the report that points to the cost burden on business, according to Whately. Instead, the government signed up only to those recommendations that promise more spending. Selective adoption of a review is not unusual; but adopting the spending half while discarding the cost-warning half invites the question of whether the exercise was ever intended to change policy.
The parliamentary arithmetic compounds the problem. The same Labour backbenchers who resist the tough choices needed to bring the welfare bill down are lining up to warn ministers off welfare savings — some on X, some writing directly to the Prime Minister to signal they would oppose benefit reform. A new Prime Minister and a new Chancellor have delivered a Budget since Milburn's interim report in May, but the blocking coalition, Whately argues, has not moved.
What does this change for young jobseekers?
In the short term, very little, unless the government acts on the cost warnings. Conservative proposals, by contrast, are specific:
- Halve employer National Insurance for under-25s, worth £1,500 a year to a business employing a young person on the National Living Wage
- Roll back what Whately calls the job-destroying measures in the Employment Rights Act
- Deliver "Get to Work", a plan requiring young Universal Credit claimants without a strong work record to show up daily — at the jobcentre or on work experience — in return for their benefit
- Deliver £36 billion of welfare savings, funding tax cuts and, in Whately's framing, letting business get on with employing people
She calls it tough love. The counterweight, she concedes, is the alternative: a generation watching their skills disappear and their detachment grow.
Whose analysis should readers trust?
This is an opinion piece by a Conservative frontbencher, and the framing is partisan. But the underlying tension is real and well documented: Milburn — a Labour figure — has produced findings his own party's government is declining to engage with on the business-cost side. "Where Milburn gets it right, we'll back him," Whately writes. The question she leaves open is whether Labour has the courage to do the same. On the evidence of the government's parliamentary response so far, that question remains unanswered.
Helen Whately is shadow secretary of state for work and pensions.
via cityam.com (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
479 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Pret, KFC and Young's press Healey to cut NI for young hires
- Mandatory Salary Disclosure Will Deepen the NEETs Crisis, Not Fix It
- Youth unemployment tops 15% as Milburn review demands welfare reset
- Milburn review demands £5.8bn a year more to fix Britain's Neet crisis
- Burnham urges early salary disclosure ahead of UK pay law