Field report S-19 / M2 · sheet /operations
Operations & RestructuringFiled from the territory
Labour Court rejects union bid over Tulbagh cannery job losses
The Labour Court rejected Afadwu’s bid to halt job losses at Premier FMCG’s Tulbagh cannery, finding fair consultation after 407 of 409 employees accepted severance packages.
- Grid
- S-19 / M2
- Surveyed
- November 17, 2026
- Reading
- 5 min read
- Correspondent
- Amara Osei

Field notes
- The Labour Court dismissed Afadwu’s urgent application on 6 November and ordered each party to pay its own costs.
- 407 of 409 affected employees accepted voluntary severance packages.
- Facilitation began on 6 August; the court heard the case on 5 October.
- Employee demands were four weeks’ pay per year and R100,000; Premier proposed two weeks per completed year and R50,000.
- The Competition Commission seeks to revoke approval of Premier’s R6.5bn Rhodes Food Group acquisition.
By Amara Osei
The Labour Court dismissed an urgent bid from the Agricultural, Food and Allied Democratic Workers’ Union (Afadwu) on 6 November, with 407 of 409 affected employees having accepted voluntary severance packages (VSPs). Acting Judge May found that Premier FMCG had followed a fair procedure in consulting employees about the closure of its Fruit Products Western Cape operation at Tulbagh.
What did the Labour Court decide?
Afadwu filed its application on 21 September, seeking to stop the section 189 retrenchment process (the statutory consultation procedure for workforce reductions) and the VSPs. The court heard the case on 5 October and delivered judgment on 6 November.
The court rejected the request to interdict (stop through a court order) the section 189A process, finding no factual basis for the union’s contention that consultation had been unfair. Acting Judge May said: “On the facts, there is nothing that supports this contention at all. In fact, the contrary seems true.”
A Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) commissioner facilitated the negotiations. Acting Judge May said the process “culminated in a negotiated agreement to offer the VSPs on the terms agreed upon.”
Each party must bear its own costs. Judge May said the union should not be discouraged from approaching the Labour Court again with a deserving case.
How were severance terms negotiated?
Facilitation, a structured negotiation over severance terms, began on 6 August. Afadwu, Solidarity, the National Union for All Sectors (Nufas), non-unionised salaried and wage representatives, and commercial and shipping representatives joined the process.
Afadwu was the only union to bring a court application challenging the process. At the third facilitation meeting, Premier presented financial information and answered questions from the parties. Employee representatives then put forward these demands:
- Severance pay: Four weeks’ wages for every year of service, with partial years of at least six months rounded up to a full year.
- Notice and minimum payment: Three months’ notice pay and a minimum severance payment of R100,000.
- Additional support: Gratuity payments for seasonal workers reaching retirement age in the coming season, continued funding for formal training programmes, including apprentices, and assistance acquiring skills to improve employment prospects.
At the following meeting, Premier presented its proposal. It covered pay, notice, service calculations and minimum payments.
- Two weeks’ wages for every completed year of service for permanent salaried and wage employees, and employees on fixed-term contracts as at July 2026.
- Backdating service calculations to 1 January 2015 for permanent employees made permanent in October 2024.
- One month’s notice pay, with work ending on 30 September and October paid as notice.
- An additional two weeks’ pay instead of notice, which Premier subsequently agreed to add.
- A minimum payment of R50,000, conditional on all affected employees accepting the VSPs.
- Where work remained outstanding, an offer of VSPs first, followed by retention on fixed-term contracts.
The parties ended that meeting on the understanding that they had reached agreement on the VSP proposal. A further meeting was scheduled for 30 September to finalise the process.
By the time Premier signed its answering affidavit (a sworn statement to the court) on 24 September, all affected salaried staff and all but two wage employees had signed VSPs. Premier subsequently reported 407 acceptances out of 409 affected employees; only one of Afadwu’s 107 members had not signed when the court heard the case.
Did a potential buyer change the outcome?
Afadwu said it gave Premier a prospective buyer’s contact details on or around 8 September. The union said the investor was willing to purchase the business as a going concern (an operating enterprise) under section 197 of the Labour Relations Act. Afadwu argued that Premier’s failure to consider the proposal had prevented meaningful consultation about alternatives to retrenchment.
Premier disputed that assertion, telling the court that no purchase offer had been made. The company argued it did not have to wait for an offer before offering VSPs, and the court held that an employer may offer voluntary severance as a measure to avoid retrenchment.
Can employees who signed return to work?
Afadwu asked the court to give employees who had signed unintentionally or under duress the option of returning to work if alternatives to retrenchment could be found. The court found no evidence that the VSPs lacked free consent and no basis to set them aside.
For the single union member who had not signed, the court said facilitation would continue. He could later challenge any dismissal as unfair, the court noted.
What remains unresolved?
Premier attributed the closure to changing global demand, pressure in export markets, rising input costs and low factory utilisation. The company argued the facility needed greater scale to compete internationally and that these pressures would have affected the business regardless of the earlier Rhodes Food Group merger.
Five Western Cape fruit producers have approached the High Court seeking an interim order (a temporary court order) compelling Premier to receive, grade and pay for fruit covered by supply agreements for the 2026/27 harvest. The producers say Premier refused to honour those contracts after announcing it would no longer buy fruit for canning.
The Competition Commission has asked the Competition Tribunal to revoke approval of Premier’s R6.5bn acquisition of Rhodes Food Group, alleging that the companies failed to disclose plans for the Tulbagh closure before approval. Premier denies withholding material information and says it decided to close after the merger; the Labour Court ruling leaves the producer contracts and merger review unresolved.
via bizcommunity.com (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
452 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Microsoft’s Italy dismissal plan for 62 staff triggers union unrest
- UKG Cuts 950 Jobs in Latest Round of Multi-Quarter Restructuring
- Nigeria Signs Port Harcourt Airport Concession With Job Pledge
- Accenture asks Court of Appeal to revive zero-compensation ruling
- Voi exits Ealing after national accreditation threat ends dispute