Field report S-79 / N7 · sheet /macro

Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory

Italy fines Meta €805 million over users’ photo consent

Italy’s Garante fined Meta €805 million over default gallery access, affecting about 20 million users, and gave the company 60 days to change the feature.

Grid
S-79 / N7
Surveyed
November 17, 2026
Reading
3 min read
Correspondent
Priya Raman
Italy fines Meta €805 million for accessing users’ photos without their consent
Fig. S-79 / N7Italy fines Meta €805 million for accessing users’ photos without their consent — Pexels / pixabay

Field notes

  1. Meta fined €805 million, about 0.47% of global turnover, by Italy’s Garante.
  2. Approximately 20 million Facebook users in Italy were affected.
  3. Garante’s inquiry began in July 2025 after a request from a Bolzano consumer group.
  4. Meta must disable the default gallery feature within 60 days and obtain separate consent to restore it.
  5. Garante left open a separate review of a cloud-gallery function introduced in 2026.

By Priya Raman

Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta €805 million for accessing photos and videos on Android smartphones without users’ separate informed consent, affecting about 20 million Facebook users in Italy.

The Italian Personal Data Protection Authority (Garante) opened its investigation in July 2025 after a consumer protection organization from Bolzano requested action. It concluded that Meta breached Italian law implementing the European ePrivacy Directive, which requires free and informed consent (approval given freely, with a clear understanding of the purpose) for access to information stored on personal devices.

A Meta spokesman told AFP that the company “strongly disagrees with the regulator’s findings and believes the fine is disproportionate to the alleged violations.” Meta intends to appeal.

What did Facebook’s gallery feature do?

The claims concern “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook,” a feature operating since 2023. It offered photos and videos from a smartphone’s memory that could be published on a social network, and the Facebook app required permission to reach the device’s gallery.

Two design choices drove the finding. The app sought permission for several functions at once, without clearly explaining that Facebook would view gallery contents to generate recommendations. It also enabled the feature by default.

Garante said that permission granted this way gave the app access to the smartphone’s entire photo and video archive, including associated metadata, or descriptive data attached to files. Users could not determine what information the application used.

Why did the consent fall short?

The legal distinction is specific: operating-system access and informed consent to gallery-based recommendations were not the same thing. Meta says users had to approve photo access at the Android level and could change those settings at any time.

Garante disagreed. Its finding rested on the absence of separate, clearly explained consent for reading the gallery, putting the consent interface, not the technical possibility of access, at the centre of the case.

The €805 million penalty reflects four considerations identified by Garante: the number of affected users, the duration of the violations, previous complaints against Meta and the company’s perceived lack of cooperation during the investigation.

The fine equals about 0.47% of Meta’s global turnover, meaning its worldwide revenue. The €805 million penalty is among the largest imposed by Italian authorities on a technology company.

What must Meta change within 60 days?

Meta must disable the gallery-recommendations feature by default within 60 days, including for users who previously granted Facebook access to their photo galleries. Garante’s remedy therefore reaches users who already granted access.

To restore the feature, Meta must obtain separate consent that clearly explains its purpose and how to disable it. That sequence reverses the default-on approach the regulator penalized.

Meta faces the 60-day product deadline alongside its appeal against the fine. The two actions address separate matters: the appeal contests the €805 million penalty, while the order specifies how the feature must operate.

What remains unresolved?

Garante separately said the investigation “did not concern the possible use of user photos to train artificial intelligence models.” Meta denies using photos that way.

The regulator has not ruled out a separate review of another function introduced in 2026. That function processes gallery contents in Meta’s cloud infrastructure, or its remote computing systems; the review would be separate from the case behind the €805 million fine.

For Meta, the immediate engineering task is to separate gallery access from unrelated app permissions and enable the recommendation feature only after separate consent. For Garante, the test is whether consent becomes informed, specific and clear about how to switch the feature off.

The stakes reach beyond one Italian product setting. Garante’s decision treats a combined permissions prompt as inadequate, setting a higher consent bar for violations affecting roughly 20 million Facebook users in Italy. Meta contests the €805 million penalty; the product deadline runs in parallel.

via observatorial.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

460 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous articleNext article »

End of sheetS-79 / N7 · November 17, 2026