Field report W-39 / N1 · sheet /macro

Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory

Deregulated States Pay 60% More for Power, Study Finds

Families in deregulated states paid about 60% more for electricity in 2025. PJM's latest capacity auction hit $333 per megawatt-day and still fell short on reliability.

Grid
W-39 / N1
Surveyed
November 16, 2026
Reading
3 min read
Correspondent
Olivia Hart
Less government regulation means higher electric bills
Fig. W-39 / N1Less government regulation means higher electric bills — AI-generated

Field notes

  1. Deregulated-state households paid roughly 60% more for electricity in 2025 than regulated-state households.
  2. Nine of the 10 most expensive contiguous U.S. states run deregulated electricity markets.
  3. PJM's latest capacity auction hit a record $333+ per megawatt-day yet failed to secure enough capacity for reliability.
  4. Deregulated-state residential rates rose at nearly double the pace of regulated states between 2024 and 2025.
  5. PJM serves 65 million people across 13 states and Washington, D.C.

Families in deregulated electricity states paid roughly 60% more for power in 2025 than households in traditionally regulated states, according to a new study by Power for Tomorrow. Nine of the 10 most expensive states in the contiguous United States operate deregulated electricity markets, the report found.

The study examined residential electricity prices across all 50 states and the District of Columbia. Its author's conclusion is blunt: nearly three decades after states began deregulating their electricity sectors in the 1990s, the promised combination of lower rates and improved service has not arrived.

J.C. Watts, a former Oklahoma Corporation Commission member who represented Oklahoma's 4th Congressional District from 1995 to 2003 and chaired the House Republican Conference, made that case in an opinion piece for the Washington Examiner. Watts writes as a self-described lifelong conservative who still believes free markets drive innovation, opportunity, and better products at lower prices.

But, he writes: "Not every policy labeled 'free-market' actually produces the benefits of a competitive marketplace."

What does the price gap mean for households?

For practitioners, the distinction comes down to accountability. In regulated states that use the vertically integrated model, utilities cannot raise rates unilaterally. They must bring their case before state regulators, demonstrate that proposed costs and investments are justified, and give stakeholders an opportunity to weigh in.

That transparency, Watts argues, keeps utilities honest, regulators engaged, and rates down. States with the most stringent government regulation of their electric utilities posted the lowest electricity rates in the study.

Deregulated states invert that structure. Customers there can buy electricity from other suppliers who, in Watts's words, "are free to charge what they can get away with." These suppliers are typically owned by out-of-state corporations, and no government regulator holds them accountable for lowering rates. The result, he writes, is that these companies nearly always charge more than the local regulated utility — "because they can."

How bad is the PJM capacity problem?

The Mid-Atlantic region supplies the clearest evidence, according to Watts. PJM, the regional electricity market serving 65 million people across 13 states and the District of Columbia, has now run three consecutive capacity auctions at historic highs.

Its most recent auction produced a record price of more than $333 per megawatt-day. Despite those higher prices, the auction still failed to secure enough generation capacity to meet projected reliability requirements.

"In other words, PJM's deregulation is delivering electricity shortages and higher costs," Watts writes. The market, in his assessment, has failed to keep pace with growing demand.

Which direction are rates heading?

The trend line favors regulated states. According to the Power for Tomorrow report, residential rates in deregulated states rose at nearly double the pace of regulated states between 2024 and 2025. Watts expects the divergence to continue, with deregulated states climbing faster for the foreseeable future.

For utilities executives, ratepayer advocates, and state policymakers, the practical stakes are straightforward. Affordable electricity, Watts argues, is not a luxury but a necessity for families, small businesses, and the country's economic future.

What should policymakers take from the numbers?

Watts concedes one point to deregulation supporters: utility regulators are not perfect. He writes that regulators should be held to the same standards of accountability and transparency the public expects from the utilities they oversee.

Still, he draws a hard line on the data: "The numbers don't lie: The regulated states are keeping electricity prices affordable, and the deregulated states are not."

His recommendation targets the states that embraced deregulation with the promise of lower prices. They should take a hard look at whether that promise has been fulfilled. Where it has not, Watts writes, policymakers should be willing to reconsider their approach.

For state regulators weighing market redesign — and for operators watching PJM's capacity shortfalls — the study adds a data point to a debate that now spans the Clinton-era restructuring wave to today's demand-growth squeeze. The 60% price gap, the $333-per-megawatt-day auction record, and the doubling pace of rate increases form the core of the case that regulation, whatever its imperfections, has kept costs closer to the ground.

via washingtonexaminer.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

456 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous articleNext article »

End of sheetW-39 / N1 · November 16, 2026