Field report W-39 / K2 · sheet /boards
Boards & GovernanceFiled from the territory
Delaware court bars indemnity after loyalty breaches
The Nov. 12 ruling links two loyalty risks—concealing material information and destroying documents—to loss of indemnification for board investigation costs.
- Grid
- W-39 / K2
- Surveyed
- November 17, 2026
- Reading
- 4 min read
- Correspondent
- Priya Raman

Field notes
- November 12, 2026: The Delaware Court of Chancery decided Sarwal v. NephroSant, Inc., C.A. No. 2023-0222-BWD.
- Withholding material information from the board breaches the duty of loyalty, according to the court.
- Destroying corporate documents during a board investigation may constitute an independent duty-of-loyalty breach.
- A director or officer found to have breached loyalty forfeits indemnification for the board investigation’s costs.
- November 17, 2026: Kevin Schwartz and Adam Goodman published their analysis of the ruling.
What did the court decide?
On November 12, 2026, the Delaware Court of Chancery ruled that a director or officer found to have breached the duty of loyalty (the fiduciary duty requiring corporate officials to act for the company rather than for their own interests) forfeits indemnification (the right to have covered corporate costs paid by the company) for the board’s investigation into that conduct.
The decision in Sarwal v. NephroSant, Inc., C.A. No. 2023-0222-BWD, identifies two related forms of conduct that can trigger loyalty scrutiny: withholding material information and destroying corporate documents during an investigation. The first breach is categorical in the summary; the second remains conditional.
Kevin Schwartz and Adam Goodman wrote on November 17, 2026: “Last week, the Delaware Court of Chancery held that a director or officer who withholds material information from the board breaches the duty of loyalty.”
Kevin Schwartz and Adam Goodman, partners at Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz, posted “Directors’ Disclosure and Document-Preservation Obligations” on November 17, 2026. Their post rests on a firm memorandum by Schwartz, Goodman, Theodore R. Furchtgott and Teniola T. Odugbesan, all at the firm, and forms part of the Delaware Law Series.
What does withholding information change?
The court’s first holding puts the board’s access to information at the centre of the analysis. On the summary’s wording, a director or officer breaches the duty of loyalty by withholding material information from the board.
The operative elements are the person’s status, the information’s materiality (its significance to the board) and the board’s exclusion from receiving it. That sequence matters for governance: disclosure to the board forms part of the conduct the court measured.
For corporate decision-makers, the strategic point is that information control becomes a legal issue when a director or officer keeps material information from the board. The board cannot assess what it does not know, so the summary places legal weight on the obstruction itself.
How does document destruction fit?
The second holding covers conduct during the board’s investigation. The court held that destruction of corporate documents during a board investigation may constitute an independent breach of the duty of loyalty. Independent means the conduct can stand as a separate loyalty problem; the word “may” also matters.
The timing is part of the holding: the destruction occurred during a board investigation, not merely during ordinary business operations. That sequence links response and recordkeeping at once and makes preservation a potential issue during the inquiry itself.
The source does not identify the documents, their quantity or their timing, and it does not say that every deletion automatically proves a breach. It reports no document-by-document account of the alleged conduct, so the careful reading remains conditional: destruction during the investigation may support an independent loyalty finding.
Why does indemnification matter?
Schwartz and Goodman set out the financial consequence: “The Court further held that a director or officer found to have breached the duty of loyalty forfeits indemnification for the costs of the board’s investigation into her conduct.”
That consequence turns a governance breach into a financial charge. The board investigation’s costs remain with the person found to have breached loyalty, rather than qualifying for indemnification from the company.
The reported consequence is specific: it concerns the board investigation’s costs. The summary provides no figure for those costs, reports no damages award and gives no information about the investigation’s duration. The decision therefore signals financial exposure without allowing that exposure to be calculated.
For the board, the benefit is cost recovery tied to a serious breach; for the director or officer, the risk extends beyond reputation to the expense of the inquiry. That does not mean the summary reports a settlement or quantified bill. It means only that the court tied indemnification for those investigation costs to the loyalty finding.
What remains unresolved?
The source does not identify the director or officer, the board’s response or the sequence of events. It also does not report whether the court ordered sanctions, broader document preservation or another remedy. The November 12 opinion may contain those details, but the available summary does not support treating them as facts.
Yet the strategic logic remains clear under the November 12 ruling: information withholding breaches loyalty, destruction during the investigation may breach loyalty independently, and a loyalty finding removes indemnification for the investigation’s costs. Candor, preservation and financial consequence now form one chain.
The record is narrow but consequential: one November 12 ruling, one November 17 legal analysis, and three linked outcomes—information withholding, document destruction and forfeiture of indemnification for the board investigation’s costs.
via corpgov.law.harvard.edu (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
460 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Delaware Insists It Remains Home After Cloudflare Injunction
- Delaware Chancery Court Leaves Litigation Funders Hidden as Dexit Accelerates
- Delaware Drafts First State Answer to SEC's Rule 14a-8 Rescission
- NYT Shareholder Demands Probe of Board Documents After Kristof Article
- Fu Yu Shareholders Mount Challenge Over Board Credentials