Field report S-15 / Q4 · sheet /leadership

CEO LeadershipFiled from the territory

Dartmouth AI conference opens with judgment, not clear answers

Dartmouth opened its 'AI at 70' conference on Oct. 29, one day after Provost Santiago Schnell resigned over undisclosed AI writing. Beilock and Thinking Machines Lab's Mira Murati chose judgment.

Grid
S-15 / Q4
Surveyed
November 17, 2026
Reading
4 min read
Correspondent
Amara Osei
‘What must remain human?’ Dartmouth AI conference opens without a clear answer
Fig. S-15 / Q4‘What must remain human?’ Dartmouth AI conference opens without a clear answer — kherrmann / pixabay

Field notes

  1. Dartmouth's 'AI at 70' conference opened on Thursday, Oct. 29, marking 70 years since the 1956 summer workshop that coined the term 'artificial intelligence.'
  2. Provost Santiago Schnell resigned Wednesday, Oct. 28, after a faculty-led review found he used AI in his writing without disclosing it.
  3. The conference runs through Saturday under the theme 'What Must Remain Human?' and opened with the session 'The Future Worth Building is Human.'
  4. Thinking Machines Lab, run by 2012 Thayer School of Engineering graduate and former OpenAI executive Mira Murati, released two open-weight models named Inkling this summer.
  5. Murati said OpenAI 'hasn't solved the alignment problem' and warned of 'loss of intellectual diversity.'
  6. Murati said of judgment: 'You develop it by actually doing the work.'

Dartmouth College's provost resigned on Wednesday, Oct. 28, after a faculty-led review found he used AI in his writing without disclosing it — one day before the college opened an anniversary conference on artificial intelligence.

Dartmouth President Sian Leah Beilock opened the "AI at 70" conference on Thursday morning, Oct. 29, with a session titled "The Future Worth Building is Human." The event runs through Saturday under the theme "What Must Remain Human?" and marks 70 years since the 1956 summer workshop at Dartmouth where researchers coined the term "artificial intelligence."

Two speakers — Beilock and Mira Murati, a 2012 Thayer School of Engineering graduate, a former OpenAI executive and now the founder of Thinking Machines Lab — kept returning to the same conclusion: judgment remains human.

What happened before the conference opened?

Provost Santiago Schnell submitted his resignation Wednesday following the faculty review. Beilock addressed the news before the main conversation began.

"It was certainly a difficult situation, but one that raises exactly the kinds of issues and challenges we want to explore over the next few days," Beilock said.

Leading on AI, she said, means "first and foremost having leaders who are modeling the transparency and human judgment we expect from our students and our scholars."

The college remains "still figuring this out, because there's no playbook yet," Beilock told the audience, and would rather set its own norms than have "industry or government do it for us."

Her prescription rests on a single line: "Anyone can get a convincing answer from AI in seconds. The hard skill now is judgment."

How will Dartmouth use AI in classrooms?

Beilock framed AI literacy as teaching students "how to know when to pick up the technology and when to put it down." Her framework permits three distinct approaches:

  • Some classes will use AI directly.
  • Some classes will prohibit it.
  • Some courses will focus on AI itself.

"A history professor might have students write tests in blue books, and all three are totally valid," she said.

Every student, she added, should "build experience with these technologies."

What is Thinking Machines Lab building?

Murati described her company in technical terms. It builds models that customers continue training on their own data, including two open-weight models named Inkling that it released this summer. The goal, she said, is to let people "truly own the intelligence versus renting it."

On risk, she warned about a small number of companies controlling the most powerful AI systems, then named a second threat that attracts less attention than concentrated money and power: "loss of intellectual diversity."

"Everyone sort of ends up inheriting the same strengths and the same blind spots," Murati said. "Instead of this very strange, weird world with so many different ideas and people disagreeing everywhere, you end up with a convergence of thinking."

OpenAI, she said, studied problems such as hallucinations and misuse before launching ChatGPT, but did not learn how to build stronger guardrails until real users ran into them. On the core safety challenge, she added, "we haven't solved the alignment problem" — the task of making sure AI systems do what people intend.

What must remain human?

The conference framed everything around that question, and Murati addressed it without answering it.

"We're gonna have to have a view on, what does it mean to have human worth in this time of machines being able to supersede us in some domains," she said. That conversation "needs to come more into the public consciousness," she added, before moving to the next question.

She located the shortfall in current systems: much of what people know "sits in their minds," "tacit" and "not perfectly articulated," and today's AI cannot capture it. Her stated aim is AI that absorbs that material and can "come towards us and understand us."

Her advice to students was practical rather than prognostic. Do not spend college guessing which jobs AI will take, she told them. "Really put something and go deep into it and really understand it deeply," she said. "The point is in pursuit of knowledge and how that changes your experience and your relationship with the world."

Beilock, a psychologist, offered a personal account: an undergraduate night in a lab learning to code in Lisp, a programming language, hunting for one missing parenthesis. "Which is, as people know, is not necessary anymore," she said. The exercise taught her to problem-solve and marked "the pivotal moment in my undergrad career where I learned I could do something I didn't think I could do."

Can judgment be protected from machines?

Asked which human capacities matter most to protect, Murati started with judgment — and immediately qualified it.

"You can say that, you know, we can hold on to our judgment and machines can do everything, but judgment doesn't work that way," she said. "You develop it by actually doing the work."

She closed by urging students to use every AI tool available. "This is an incredibly precious time to have these superpowers in your hands," she said. "I am jealous."

The risks she described concerned how AI gets built and who controls it, not which tasks people should keep performing themselves. On the question the conference was built around, the evidence remains unsettled: two speakers offered different answers, and neither closed the session.

via nhbr.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.

452 articles

Filed under

Adjacent sheets

« Previous articleNext article »

End of sheetS-15 / Q4 · November 17, 2026