Field report W-61 / K1 · sheet /boards
Boards & GovernanceFiled from the territory
CBI tells Reynolds: scrap binding pay votes to revive London's edge
The CBI and Deloitte want shareholder pay votes made non-binding and employee share schemes widened, as Reynolds weighs cutting corporate red tape by 25 per cent.
- Grid
- W-61 / K1
- Surveyed
- November 16, 2026
- Reading
- 3 min read
- Correspondent
- Priya Raman

Field notes
- The CBI and Deloitte have called on Jonathan Reynolds to scrap binding shareholder votes on executive pay
- The report lands as government targets a 25 per cent cut in the administrative burden on firms by 2030
- Only six FTSE 100 companies received an 'against' recommendation on pay plans this year, per a proxy voting agency
- Workers can currently get up to £3,600 per year in tax-free shares if held in trust for five years or more
- CBI chair Cressida Hogg said the framework would maintain shareholder accountability while giving boards flexibility
The Confederation of British Industry has told Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds to scrap binding shareholder votes on executive pay, arguing the change would let top companies act faster and keep London's markets competitive.
The recommendation sits at the centre of a joint CBI-Deloitte report delivered as Reynolds weighs how to cut the administrative burden on firms by 25 per cent by 2030. That target is a government commitment, and the report offers him a menu of deregulatory options to hit it.
The proposal is precise in its mechanics. Shareholder votes on remuneration (the formal approval process for boardroom pay packets) would still happen, but they would no longer bind the company. Boards could, in defined circumstances, overrule the investors who own the business.
When would boards get the final say?
Industry analysts backing the idea point to two scenarios. First, a listed company hunting for a new chief executive during a turnaround, where a pay package needs to move quickly. Second, an incumbent executive holding an offer from a US competitor — a real risk, given the persistent pay gap between FTSE 100 bosses and their Wall Street peers.
The argument runs that letting managers set pay in these situations lets companies be, in the report's words, "more agile and responsive" and maximise stakeholder interests.
Is investor resistance actually a problem?
The evidence, on the face of it, says no. Only six FTSE 100 companies received a recommendation 'against' their remuneration plans this year, according to an influential proxy voting agency (firms that advise institutional investors how to vote). That low level of dissent, the report suggests, shows investors are already flexible on pay proposals — so removing the binding vote would formalise what practice already allows.
There is precedent for loosening pay constraints. Liz Truss's move to remove the EU-era cap on bankers' bonuses remains one of the only policies from her brief premiership that has survived.
What else is in the report?
Beyond pay votes, the CBI and Deloitte push a set of what they call low-cost options for growth:
- Expand employee share schemes, potentially extending coverage to some gig-economy workers
- Improve the tax advantages attached to those schemes
- Index the reliefs to inflation so they hold their value year on year
- Shorten the holding period for full share incentive plan (SIP) tax benefits
The numbers matter here. Under current rules, workers can receive free shares worth up to £3,600 per year tax-free, provided the shares stay in a trust for five years or more. The report wants that five-year lock-in cut and the relief threshold raised annually.
What has the CBI's chair said?
Cressida Hogg, chair of the CBI and formerly of BAE Systems, framed the package as a balance between boardroom freedom and accountability. A new framework, she said, would give boards "the trust and flexibility to make decisions in the long-term interests of their businesses, while maintaining shareholder accountability".
"The recommendations provide practical steps towards achieving this, alongside modernising employee share ownership so more people can benefit from business success," Hogg said.
Her phrasing does the political work. Flexibility for boards, accountability for shareholders, wider ownership for staff — a three-part pitch aimed squarely at a government hunting for growth levers that cost the Treasury little.
The Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade was approached for comment.
For Reynolds, the decision point is straightforward. The 25 per cent red-tape reduction target needs policy attached to it, and the CBI-Deloitte report hands him a ready-made list. Whether he takes the politically sensitive step of weakening shareholder democracy on pay is now the question sitting in his in-tray.
via cityam.com (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
459 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Legal & General confirms 1,000 job cuts by mid-2027 as buyouts surge
- Activist DGB Investments Offers Ethan Allen CEO an Exit Lane, Not a Truce
- SEC Proposes Biggest Pay Disclosure Overhaul Since 2006
- Tesla board to shareholders: approve Musk pay or face fallout
- Harvard Forum Publishes 2025 U.S. Governance Post-Season Review