Field report NW-46 / M7 · sheet /macro
Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory
Billionaires Spent $400 Million Killing California's Wealth Tax — and Lost Elsewhere
California's 5% billionaire wealth tax failed after a $400 million opposition campaign, yet voters approved all three high-earner income-tax measures on state ballots.
- Grid
- NW-46 / M7
- Surveyed
- November 17, 2026
- Reading
- 5 min read
- Correspondent
- Sophie Lindqvist

Field notes
- Billionaires including Sergey Brin spent nearly $400 million defeating California's Proposition 40, a one-time 5% tax on roughly 200 billionaires' net worth.
- All three 2026 ballot measures raising or preserving high-earner income taxes passed — in Washington, Colorado and California.
- California's Proposition 3 makes permanent surcharges from 10.3% to 12.3% on incomes above $360,000, set to expire in 2031.
- New York City's pied-à-terre tax, launched in July, imposes surcharges of up to 6.5% on non-primary condos and co-ops worth $1 million or more.
- More than 75% of Cook County, Illinois voters backed a nonbinding 3% millionaire surcharge referendum.
Nearly $400 million — that is what Google co-founder Sergey Brin and several other billionaires spent to defeat California's Proposition 40, a one-time 5% levy on the net worth of the state's roughly 200 billionaires. The spending worked. A majority of California voters rejected the measure in the 2026 midterms, capping the most expensive ballot fight of the cycle.
The defeat, however, tells only half the story. Voters approved all three income-tax measures on state ballots that targeted or protected higher rates on the wealthy. The pattern suggests a narrower conclusion than either camp claims: Americans will tax rich people's income, but not their wealth — at least not yet.
Emmanuel Saez, the University of California, Berkeley economist who helped design Proposition 40, did not mince words after the loss. "Today oligarchy has won," he said. That verdict is quotable, but it is also untested — the same electorate that rejected the wealth tax voted to make its high-earner income surcharges permanent.
What did the ballot measures actually decide?
Five states voted on major income-tax changes in the midterms. Three of the initiatives raised or preserved taxes on high earners; all three prevailed.
- Washington: Voters upheld the state's new 9.9% income tax on household income above $1 million. The "millionaire's tax," signed into law earlier in 2026, is Washington's first personal income tax.
- Colorado: Voters rejected Proposition 136, which would have capped the state income tax rate at 4.4%, and approved Amendment 87, a graduated income tax raising rates on households and businesses with incomes over $500,000.
- California: Alongside the Proposition 40 defeat, voters approved Proposition 3, making permanent the 2012 high-earner surcharges that were set to expire in 2031. The inflation-adjusted rates start at 10.3% for incomes of $360,000 and reach 12.3% above $721,000.
In August 2026, Missouri voters had already overwhelmingly rejected an amendment that would have forced lawmakers to eliminate the state income tax — a change worth $8.5 billion in annual revenue, which a higher sales tax would have replaced. Analysts noted the sales-tax substitute would have hit low-income taxpayers hardest.
The two losses for the tax-the-rich side came in North Carolina and Iowa, where voters approved constitutional amendments making future high-earner taxes harder to enact. Neither state voted directly on such a tax. North Carolina's governor, Josh Stein, called his state's amendment a "millionaire protection cap."
What are legislatures doing without ballots?
State lawmakers, spared a campaign against billionaire-funded opposition, moved faster than voters in several states.
- Maine approved a 1% surcharge on income over $1 million in April 2026.
- Hawaii created a new 13% income bracket in May for single taxpayers above $500,000 or joint filers above $1 million, paired with rate cuts for lower brackets.
- Rhode Island enacted a millionaires' surcharge in June, phasing in over three years to a maximum 3%.
These follow a longer arc. New York passed one of the first high-earner income taxes in 2009; Washington, D.C., Massachusetts and Maryland followed in 2022, 2023 and 2025, respectively.
Are second homes the easier target?
A second front targets expensive property that is not a primary residence — an approach that has succeeded in both legislatures and voting booths, though not everywhere.
- Montana approved a tiered property tax in April 2025, effective Jan. 1, 2026, setting rates at 1.9% for vacation homes and short-term rentals while primary residences pay lower tiered homestead rates.
- New York City launched its "pied-à-terre tax" in July: an annual surcharge of 0.8% to 1.3% on single-family homes worth $5 million or more, and 4% to 6.5% on condos and co-ops worth $1 million or more, applying only to non-primary residences.
- Rhode Island introduced a matching surcharge at the same time: $2.50 per $500 of assessed value above $1 million on non-primary residences.
- Boulder, Colorado approved a residential vacancy tax on Nov. 3, roughly $4,000 a year per home empty more than half the year, effective 2028.
The record here is mixed, a caveat advocates rarely mention. A second-home tax failed in Crested Butte, Colorado. San Diego rejected a similar vacant-homes surcharge.
Why income beats wealth at the ballot box
The practical answer is arithmetic. Income taxes ride on annual tax filings that already exist, state and federal alike. Wealth taxes require annual valuations of businesses, farmland, artwork and intellectual property — assets that are hard to estimate and harder to defend in court. The only routine valuation of wealth occurs at death, for large estates.
Property taxes share income tax's administrative advantage. Municipalities already produce annual assessments, so a surcharge on a second home adds little compliance cost.
The trade-off is capacity. Taxing income instead of wealth limits how much revenue can be raised from those most able to pay, because most wealthy people convert little of their wealth into income — selling stock being the common exception.
What does this change for the next cycle?
More than 75% of voters in Cook County, Illinois — home to Chicago — backed a nonbinding referendum for a 3% surcharge on incomes over $1 million. It authorizes nothing. It does show where the votes are.
Even Bill Gates has said a "billionaire's tax" will be necessary. The unanswered question is what kind: a tax on wealth, which lost in California despite its backers' economics, or taxes on income and second homes, which keep winning.
via fortune.com/feed/ (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
479 articles
Adjacent sheets
- California wealth-tax vote nears defeat amid a $300 million paradox
- Sergey Brin's $102 Million Sank California's Billionaire Tax
- California Billionaires Spent $300 Million to Kill the Wealth Tax — and Won
- California Rejects Prop 40 Billionaire Tax After $130 Million Tech Push
- California Voters Reject Proposition 40 Billionaire Wealth Tax