Field report W-39 / L3 · sheet /macro
Boardroom MacroFiled from the territory
Andreessen Tells Fed AI Will Disappoint Utopians and Doomers Alike
Marc Andreessen told the San Francisco Fed that AI cannot legally enter health care, education and housing, so both boom forecasts and job-loss fears will disappoint.
- Grid
- W-39 / L3
- Surveyed
- November 18, 2026
- Reading
- 5 min read
- Correspondent
- Amara Osei

Field notes
- Andreessen co-leads the Fed's Productivity and Jobs Task Force; recommendations due by year-end, next rate decision Dec. 9.
- Health care stood at 18% of US GDP in 2024, or $5.3 trillion, per CMS actuaries; Andreessen projected it could reach 80%.
- The Fed held rates at 3.75% to 4% on Oct. 28; Andreessen Horowitz raised more than $15 billion in January.
- AI tools save Providence physicians two to four hours per day, CEO Erik Wexler said.
- Workers pay an average $7,471 a year toward family health coverage, up 9% from 2025, per KFF.
"Both utopians and the doomers are going to be disappointed" by AI, Marc Andreessen told the Federal Reserve's AI conference in San Francisco on Monday — "specifically disappointed by the scope and magnitude of the real-world impact, and specifically the economic impact."
Andreessen co-leads the Fed's Productivity and Jobs Task Force, which Chairman Kevin Warsh established to advise on what super intelligence ("SI," the White House's preferred term) will do to growth, prices and jobs. His argument, previewed for the group's year-end report, is that AI will not cure William Baumol's "cost disease" — the economic principle explaining why flat-screen TVs get cheaper while hospital bills, tuition and rent rise — and could make it worse.
What does the task force actually do?
The panel is advisory. Andreessen has no vote on interest rates. He co-leads the group with Stanford economist Charles Jones and Microsoft executive Asha Sharma, one of five outside panels the Fed named in June to rethink the central bank's operations.
- Its charge, per the Fed, is to assess "new general-purpose technologies, including super intelligence, to inform the Federal Reserve's policy judgments."
- Recommendations are due by year-end, though Warsh said in October that "some, but not all" panels would report on time.
- The Fed's task force page lists no ethics or recusal terms.
- Andreessen's firm, Andreessen Horowitz, raised more than $15 billion in new funds in January.
The messenger matters here. Andreessen's 2023 "Techno-Optimist Manifesto" declared "We believe in accelerationism" and named stagnation as the enemy. This is the man who told the Fed on Monday that stagnation might prevail.
What are the Fed's three scenarios?
Warsh opened the conference with three "illustrative scenarios" Fed board staff have begun to evaluate. In the first, AI lifts productivity, gains are broadly shared and the economy stays near full employment. In the second, growth runs above trend but automation pushes unemployment higher. In the third, AI "could disappoint after significant capital investment and stock market gains," with stocks falling and the economy recovering "without the productivity gains."
Andreessen's version is duller: most of the economy never admits AI at all. He splits the economy in two. "Fast sectors" — consumer electronics, media, commodity goods — adopt technology quickly and share "rapidly falling prices." "Slow sectors" — health care, education, housing, law and government — "are not legally allowed to have rapid change, like literally not."
"The machine cannot get an MD, cannot prescribe medication," he said. "The machine cannot get admitted to the bar." Slow sectors pair restricted supply with subsidized demand. "So, of course, prices can only go up."
His endpoint is stark. Health care is "already a fifth of US GDP and I don't see why it doesn't go to a fourth, a third and then half and then ultimately 80%." The government's count is 18% of GDP in 2024, or $5.3 trillion, per CMS actuaries. "You might interpret this as good news because it means the AI revolution is not going to destroy all the jobs or kill everybody," he said. "We may just continue to stagnate."
He still called himself "extremely optimistic" and likened AI to "this elixir to boost productivity growth." But policy choices, he said, "are going to matter actually way more than what the technology is capable of," because without them "the technology will simply not get rolled out."
How old is this diagnosis?
Baumol, the late NYU and Princeton economist, worked out cost disease in the 1960s from the economics of performing arts: a string quartet still needs four musicians, paid wages set by a more productive economy. In his 2012 book "The Cost Disease," Baumol projected health costs could rise from 15% of average income in 2005 to 62% by 2105, writing that "society can afford them" — the real threat being "foolish public policy."
Jones, on leave at Anthropic and quiet because the company is preparing to go public, co-authored a 2017 NBER paper arguing "growth may be constrained not by what we are good at but rather by what is essential and yet hard to improve," crediting Baumol.
San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly asked executives for their "weak link." Erik Wexler, CEO of Providence, the seven-state hospital system, answered: "We're part of the weak link." State-by-state AI rules make it feel "almost like sometimes being in seven different countries." Yet Wexler also complicated the thesis: AI note-taking tools save some physicians "two to four hours of time a day," described as "life-changing" — savings inside a slow sector that may never reach the price of a hospital visit.
Where does this leave the chair?
Andreessen's forecast cuts against Warsh's pre-chair position, laid out in a Wall Street Journal op-ed late last year, that AI "will be a significant disinflationary force." As chair, Warsh has hedged: "My judgment is we have seen an improvement in productivity; we can't measure it precisely," he told reporters on Oct. 28, noting most gains "precede everything we're talking about." The Fed held rates at 3.75% to 4% that day.
On Monday, Warsh did not push back. He closed "cautiously optimistic," calling this "a hinge point for the US economy." Recommendations are due by year-end; the next rate decision comes Dec. 9. Andreessen framed the choice as "a political economy" question: "what kind of pace of change do we want, how much productivity growth do we actually want?"
via fortune.com/feed/ (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in corporate strategy and chief-executive leadership at CEO Frontier.
449 articles
Adjacent sheets
- Warsh presents AI growth case while leaving Fed inflation risk aside
- Fed Chairman Warsh Orders Staff to Build AI Contingency Scenarios
- Fed Models Three AI Futures for Jobs, Growth and Rates
- Oxford Economics Warns Boom Is Sowing Seeds of a Deeper Recession
- Andreessen Predicts Healthcare Could Swallow 80% of US GDP as AI Stalls